Call
Menu

Reviews

Overall Rating / 322 Total 1st-Party Reviews

4.9 Out of
5 Stars

Good 'N Plenty Restaurant

5.0 out of 5 stars
Linda L - June 4, 2020

First we noticed how beautiful the location is. Then we noticed the amazing smells sneaking out of the building. We chose the family style dining. Everything was wonderful! The fried chicken is probably the best we ever had. And you can't leave with out visiting the gift shop. We have told everyone we know that if they're ever in Lancaster, there's only one place to eat!

Share

5.0 out of 5 stars
T M - June 3, 2020

So I remember my mom taking me here when I was younger. An let me tell you the food, people, staff are very welcoming. Was my husband and kids first time and we visit once a year but eat there twice!😁

Share

5.0 out of 5 stars
Barbara H - May 11, 2020

We took Mother's Day dinner to my parents and my in-laws. Everyone raved about how wonderful everything tasted. Excellent in quality and plenty of quantity! It should be called Best and Plenty...

Share

5.0 out of 5 stars
Mary S - August 3, 2019

I enjoy coming to Good and Plenty. The food id always delicious and the service is usually excellent. I think I only ever had and I only ever had one bad time, I reported and every thing was good after that. I not only recommend it I personally bring people with me.

Share

5.0 out of 5 stars
Recent Customer G - July 11, 2019

Good 'N Plenty is our go-to place to eat when we are in the area. We always enjoy the authentic Amish food and atmosphere plus the great service and hospitality of the staff. We also like the bakery and the gift shop.

Share

Sort Reviews by: Date or Rating