Reviews

Overall Rating / 206 Total 1st-Party Reviews

4.9 Out of
5 Stars

Good 'N Plenty Restaurant

5.0 out of 5 stars
- July 6, 2018

We eat at Good and Plenty around 3 times a year. We live in south jersey so we look forward to our day trips up to Lancaster Couny. We eat menu dining in the farmhouse. We love the food, the service is great, and the waitresses are very friendly. Besides that we order take out every Memorial Day and Labor Day weekend. We get enough food to feed 13 of us. We order ahead chicken mashed potatoes, noodles, and rolls. It is always ready when we get there and always very warm and fresh. Love it! We eat lunch with our Amish friends! Lots of food, good fellowship.and just delicious. I usually always get a pie or two to bring home. Love the lattice work on the top! Good and Plenty won’t disappoint! Try it you will love it!

Share

5.0 out of 5 stars
- July 5, 2018

The experience was Great. The servers were very cordial and friendly. The food was excellent.

Share

5.0 out of 5 stars
- June 3, 2018

I always loved there food. I had some friends down here for the first time . They where very happy with there meals. I always tell people if you love Pa. Dutch food this is the place to eat. The food is always good. And you never go home hungry .

Share

5.0 out of 5 stars
- May 31, 2018

Everything from the homemade butter for the bread to the ham and chicken brought to our table was part of the best dinner I've ever had. Definitely wish we had a Good 'N Plenty in New York

Share

5.0 out of 5 stars
- May 19, 2018

We just loved the meal! We don't eat buffets anymore so your new menu was perfect. Just as Good and Plenty as it was in the late 60's and 70's. We have found a place to return to with our bus groups! Thank you!

Share

Sort Reviews by: Date or Rating