Menu Dining

 Menu Dining

We now serve daily specials! To see what is available, view our daily specials menu.

View Daily Specials 

Be sure to sign up for our monthly emails, which deliver our menu dining specials and coupons directly to your inbox.

Receive Monthly Dining Specials »

Good N’ Plenty Customer Favorites

Our World Famous Fried Chicken —Your choice of two pieces of white or dark chicken with your choice of two sides 11.45

PA Dutch Sampler — One piece of white or dark chicken, one slice of meat loaf and a serving of pork and sauerkraut with your choice of two sides 12.45

Our Own Meatloaf —A family recipe served with your choice of two sides 11.45

Our Own Baked Chicken Pie — A blend of chicken and vegetables in gravy baked in our own pie crust with two sides 12.45 (not available for children’s menu)

Roast Beef— Slow roasted, sliced and served with your choice of two sides 12.45

Roast Turkey — Oven roasted with your choice of two sides 11.45

Pork and Sauerkraut — A Lancaster County tradition served with your choice of two sides 11.45

Baked Lancaster County Ham — Fresh from our local supplier and served with your choice of two sides 11.45

Steamed Fish — Available upon request with your choice of two sides 9.95 (Please allow 10 minutes)

Hot Open Face Roast Beef — Served with gravy on your choice of our own white or wheat bread with choice of two sides 12.45

Hot Open Face Roast Turkey— Served with gravy on your choice of our own white or wheat bread with choice of two sides 11.45

Vegetable Platter — Your choice of FOUR sides 8.4

Sides

Extra sides available 2.49 per side

Fresh Whipped Potatoes with gravy on the side

Brown Buttered Noodles — A PA Dutch tradition

French Fries

Sweet Corn

Vegetable of the Day — Please ask your friendly server for today’s selection

Filling – A PA Dutch tradition made with our own homepage bread

Corn Nuggets — Deep fried and served with syrup

Chow Chow —This cold Amish dish was said to be created from the odd amounts of fresh vegetables left over from canning – carrots, onions, cauliflower, celery, peppers and beans were combined with lots of vinegar and a touch of sugar for a unique taste experience

Our Own Pepper Cabbage — This cold side is a blend of shredded green cabbage, green peppers an carrots mixed with vinegar and a touch of sugar

Side Salad— Iceberg, shredded carrots, tomatoes, onions and our own croutons with your choice of dressing

Applesauce — Everyone’s favorite – cinnamon available upon request

Cottage Cheese — A cheese curd product with a mild flavor, delicious with apple butter or on green salads

Red Eggs with Beets

Potato Salad — Made fresh in our kitchen

Macaroni Salad — Made fresh in our kitchen

Cole Slaw— Shredded cabbage and carrots in creamy mayonnaise dressing

Good ‘N Plenty Salad Selections

All salads served with our own homemade white and wheat bread, apple butter and whipped butter
Ceasar Salad – Fresh cut romaine lettuce and shredded Parmesan tossed with creamy Caesar dressing, topped with our croutons $7.45     Add grilled chicken breast $9.45

Cook’s Salad – Mixed greens with your choice of two protein salads (chicken, tuna, egg and olive), choice of our own potato or macaroni salad, complete with red beet egg, red beets, pickle spear and whole wheat crackers $12.49

Honey Mustard Chicken Salad – Your choice of grilled chicken or breaded white meat chicken nuggets mixed with flavorful honey mustard dressing nestled in a salad of mixed greens, julienne carrots, grape tomatoes and cucumber slices $12.00

Apple Harvest Salad – Chopped romaine gently tossed with red seedless grapes and chopped walnuts and garnished with Granny Smith apple slices, served with a honey yogurt dressing $9.45

Strawberry and Spinach Salad – Tender baby spinach, juicy strawberries and sliced almonds tossed gently with balsamic vinaigrette and served with a wedge of farmer’s cheese $12.00

Dressing Options

Sandwich Options

Your choice of our own white or wheat bread, marble rye pumpernickel or Kaiser
Reuben – Thinly sliced corned beef or turkey breast on your choice of toasted bread with Swiss cheese, sauerkraut and Thousand Island dressing $9.45

Rachel – Thinly sliced turkey breast or corned beef on your choice of toasted bread with Swiss cheese and creamy slaw $9.45

Pulled Pork Barbecue – Served warm on your choice of bread with pickle spear and your choice of chips or pepper cabbage $9.45
Smoked Ham or Roast Turkey – On your choice of bread with American or Swiss Cheese, lettuce, tomato, chips and pickle Ham – $7.25   Turkey – $7.25

Choice of Chicken, Tuna or Egg and Olive Salad – Served on your choice of bread with lettuce, tomato, chips and pickle $8.45

Breaded Haddock Filet – Served on your choice of bread with homemade tartar sauce, lettuce, chips and pickle $8.95

Breaded Chicken Filet – Served on your choice of bread with lettuce, chips and pickle $8.95

Add a side salad for $2.49

Soup of the Day

Signature Chicken Corn Soup available daily
Cup – $2.95   Bowl – $3.95 – Ask your friendly server for today’s soup selection
Cup of Soup and Half Cold Sandwich of Choice $7.25

Bottomless Drinks

$2.29 per drink – free refills