Bakery

Fresh Baked Goods Made from Scratch Daily

PA Dutch Favorites and More!

bakery kitchen and counterVisit us in the bakery, located on our lower level.

Our world famous Good ’N Plenty Bakery, located on the restaurant’s Lower Level, is filled with traditional PA Dutch favorites, seasonal treats, and award-winning delights.

Our skilled and experienced bakers are busy every day making our own fresh baked bread, family recipe shoo-fly pie, whoopie pies, cakes, cookies, sticky buns, and more – all from scratch.

We are happy to serve you by making yummy suggestions when you stop in or we can take orders over the phone. Use Good ’N Plenty as your personal baker – we do the work, you bask in the compliments!

Bakery Hours

Mon-Thurs: 8:00am-7:00pm | Fri-Sat: 8:00am-8:00pm | Sun: 11:00am-5:00pm
Phone: 717-394-7111

sticky buns with nuts
baker weighing dough
six plain sticky buns
baker carrying bread tray

Baked Goods Ready for Takeout

Every day, our bakers make traditional PA Dutch that are ready for you to grab and go.

These items typically include:

  • Fresh Baked Bread. White and wheat, sliced or unsliced.
  • Shoo-fly Pie. Traditional wet-bottom style – a local favorite!
  • Whoopie Pies. Classic chocolate, pumpkin, and red velvet.
  • Cookies. Chocolate chip, oatmeal raisin, snickerdoodles, and other varieties.
  • Sticky Buns. With nuts, raisins, and plain.

bakery wide angleLeave the baking to us! Grab a basket and pick up dinner rolls for the week or delicious treats for your next gathering with family and friends.

Cakes, Special Occasions, and Holiday Orders

If you’d like to order ahead, please call us at 717-394-7111. You can pay for your order when you pick it up.

Holiday Order Deadlines. Please place orders at least 2 days before the Easter and Thanksgiving holidays. The last day to pick up orders for Christmas is December 23.

Discounted Bakery Items

Sometimes we have discounted items in stock from the previous day (“day-olds”) that we offer at a discounted price.